CITY OF PACIFIC GROVE

300 FOREST AVENUE

PACIFIC GROVE, CALIFORNIA 93950

TELEPHONE (831) 648-3190 • FAX (831) 648-3184

 

NOTICE OF REGULAR MEETING

 

PLANNING COMMISSION

 

DATE & TIME:           THURSDAY, April 2, 2009 – 6:00 P.M.

LOCATION:                CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS – 300 FOREST AVENUE, PACIFIC GROVE

 

Copies of the agenda packet are available for review at the Pacific Grove Library located at 550 Central Avenue; the Community Development Department, upstairs  in City Hall at 300 Forest Avenue, Pacific Grove; and on the internet at: http://www.ci.pg.ca.us/boards/pla.htm.

 

 

MEETING AGENDA:

 

1.         Call to Order

 

2.         Roll Call -- Planning Commission Members:  Linda Bailey (Vice-Chair), Bob Davis,

            Steven MacDonald, Eric Miller, Craig Riddell (Chair), Sally Smith, Max Perelman

 

3.         Approval of Minutes

           

            The March 17, 2009 Site Review Meeting and March 19, 2009 Regular Meeting were cancelled due to lack of a quorum.

 

4.         Oral Communications

            (Comments from the audience will not receive Planning Commission action.  Comments must deal with matters subject to the jurisdiction of the Planning Commission and will be limited to three minutes.  Comments regarding agenda items not on the Consent Agenda shall be heard prior to the consideration of such items at the time such items are called.  Whenever possible, letters should be submitted to the Planning Commission in advance of the meeting.)

 

5.         Items to be Continued or Withdrawn: 

A.        Request for a continuance to the April 16, 2009 Regular Meeting:  Six month review of Use Permit Application No. 2964-08, Operation of a Farmers’ Market every Monday on Lighthouse Avenue in the Public Street Right-of-Way between Forest Avenue and 18th Streets (Everyone’s Harvest, Iris Peppard, Executive Director), in order to allow additional time for the Planning Commission subcommittee to meet with the market manager and interested community members.

          

CONSENT AGENDA: None

 

6.         (The Consent Agenda consists of those items which are routine and for which a staff recommendation has been prepared.  A Planning Commissioner, member of the audience or staff may request that an item be placed on the regular agenda for further discussion.  One motion will cover all items on the Consent Agenda.  The motion to approve will authorize the action or recommendation indicated.)

 

REGULAR AGENDA:

 

7A.

PROJECT ADDRESS:                 1017 Forest Avenue

APPLICANT:                               Miguel Estrada, owner

APPLICATION:                          Architectural Approval #3819-08

PROJECT DESCRIPTION:        A public hearing on the Planning Commission’s call for review of the Architectural Review Board’s action on Architectural Approval #3819-08, a proposed project to change the roof material at 1017 Forest Avenue from wood shake to tile.

LEGAL DESCRIPTION:            Lot 5, Block 4, Country Club Heights Tract, Assessors’ Parcel Number 006-701-020-000

ZONE DISTRICT:                       R-1

GENERAL PLAN

DESIGNATION:                          Medium Density Residential 7.3 du/acre

CEQA STATUS:                          Class 3 Categorical Exemption

 

Recommended Action:                    Approve Project.

 

Note:  This item was on the March 19, 2009 meeting agenda.  Please see the March 19, 2009 agenda packet for the staff report and documents associated with this project.

 

7B.

A public hearing to consider:         Architectural Approval Application AA 3753-08 on appeal  

 

PROJECT ADDRESS:                 245 Willow

APPLICANT:                               Steve and Jean Romberg

APPLICATION:                          AA 3753-08

PROJECT DESCRIPTION:        Exterior alteration and addition to an existing non-conforming garage, accessed from Granite Street

LEGAL DESCRIPTION:           

ZONE DISTRICT:                       R-1

GENERAL PLAN

DESIGNATION:                         

CEQA STATUS:                          Class 3 Categorical Exemption      

STAFF:                                         Sarah Hardgrave, Senior Planner

 

Recommended Action: Staff recommends final architectural approval of the proposed design alternative, based on the conceptual approval granted by the Planning Commission on January 22, 2009.

 

7C.

A public hearing to consider:         Use Permit #2997-09 and Variance #09-1726

 

PROJECT ADDRESS:                 225 Central

APPLICANT:                               The Bridge Restoration Ministry (Lee Underwood, Chair)

APPLICATION:                          Use Permit #2997-09 and Variance #09-1726

PROJECT DESCRIPTION:        Use Permit Application #2997-09 is to expand the number of residents and participants in the Bridge Restoration Ministry at 225 Central Avenue from six to twelve, proposed as a rooming or boarding house under Municipal Code Section 23.28.020(d), and Variance Application #09-1726 is for an exception to the garage parking requirement under Municipal Code Section 23.64.190(c).  No exterior or interior modifications to the existing building are proposed.  The six existing uncovered parking spaces meet the minimum number of spaces required.

LEGAL DESCRIPTION:            Lot 1, Portions of Lots 2 & 4, Block 1, Pacific Grove Retreat (APN 006-225-001-000)

ZONE DISTRICT:                       R-4

GENERAL PLAN

DESIGNATION:                          HDR 19.8

CEQA STATUS:                          Class 1 Categorical Exemption

 

RECOMMENDED ACTION:       Approve project.

 

8.         City Council Actions -- Staff will provide a summary report on recent council actions.

            Reference:  Lynn Burgess, AICP, Chief Planner

 

9.         Architectural Review Board Actions -- Staff will provide a summary report on recent actions of the

            Architectural Review Board.

 

A.     Site Review  – March 24, 2009

B.     Regular Meeting – March 24, 2009

            Reference:  Sarah Hardgrave, Senior Planner

 

10.       Historic Resource Committee Actions -- Staff will provide a summary report on recent actions of the

            Historic Resource Committee.

 

11.       Administrative Hearings

 

12.       Site Plan Review Committee Actions  -- Staff will provide a summary report on recent actions of the

            Site Plan Review Committee.

 

A.     Special Meeting  – March 24, 2009

            Reference:  Sarah Hardgrave, Senior Planner

 

13.       Correspondence -- Communications relevant to the jurisdiction of the Planning Commission are attached under this agenda item.

 

14.       Committee Reports -- Subcommittees of the Planning Commission will provide a summary report of their recent activities.

 

15.       Reports of Commissioners

Commissioners may ask a question for clarification, make a brief announcement or make a brief report on his or her activities. In addition, the Commission may provide a referral to staff or other resources for factual information, request staff to report back to the body at a subsequent meeting concerning a City matter or direct staff to place a request to agendize a matter of business on a future agenda (G.C. 54954.2).

 

16.       Reports of the Community Development Department’s Chief Planner

                        Reference:  Lynn Burgess, AICP

 

16.       Adjournment

 

 

NOTE:  Please note that Section 65009(b)(2) of the California Government Code provides that legal challenges to the City's action on A project may be limited to only those issues raised in testimony during the public hearing process.

 

THE PLANNING COMMISSION WILL NOT CONSIDER ANY NEW ITEMS AFTER 9:00 P.M.  ANY ITEMS REMAINING ON THE AGENDA WILL BE CONTINUED EITHER TO THE NEXT REGULAR MEETING OR A SPECIAL MEETING AT THE DISCRETION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION.

 

NOTICE TO APPLICANTS

I.       SITE REVIEW

If the project, at the time of the site review, is not visible without entering a structure or yard area, the applicant must be present or make arrangements to show the project area.

 

II.      APPEARANCE BY APPLICANT OR REPRESENTATIVE

The applicant or his/her representative must be present at the public hearing meeting for which the item is scheduled.  If unable to attend, the applicant must submit a written request for continuance prior to the meeting.  The Commission may deny an item if the applicant or representative is not present and if a continuance is not requested.

 

III.    SUBMITTAL OF WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS

In order to receive due consideration by the Planning Commission, written communications pertaining to agenda items should be submitted to the Community Development Department by 12:00 noon on the Tuesday prior to the meeting.  Materials submitted subsequent to that time, or directly to the Commission at the meeting, may, at the Commission's discretion, result in a continuance of the item.

 

IV.    APPEALS AND APPEAL PERIOD

Decisions rendered by the Planning Commission may be appealed to the City Council using a form available at the Community Development Department.  An appeal using this appeal form plus an appeal fee must be filed with the Community Development Department within 10 days of the action being appealed.

 

NOTE:  The aforementioned appeal period not withstanding, the City Council reserves the right to call up for review Planning Commission decisions until its next regularly scheduled meeting. Please check with the staff if you have any questions about this.

 

V.     BUILDING PERMIT

Planning Commission approval of an application does not constitute an approval to do any construction without a building permit.  Please contact the Building Division at 648-3183 for information about building permits.

 

No building permit pertaining to a Planning Commission action may be issued until the 10-day appeal period and the City Council's call up period has passed.

 

VI.    NOTICE OF EXEMPTION UNDER THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT

Applicants with approved projects that have been deemed statutorily or categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) may file a Notice of Exemption (NOE) directly with the Monterey County Clerk in order to reduce the CEQA challenge period from 180 days to 35 days (CEQA Guidelines Section 15062).  Applicants wishing to file the NOE should contact their planner for instructions on how to file the notice with Monterey County.  Please note the Monterey County Clerk has a $50 filing fee for a NOE. 

 

Filing of a NOE by the City of Pacific Grove is not required.  CEQA determinations are included in the public hearing notices for all projects.

 

VII.   EFFECTIVE DATE OF ENTITLEMENT

PLEASE NOTE THAT YOUR USE PERMIT/VARIANCE DOES NOT BECOME EFFECTIVE AND THEREFORE NEITHER A BUILDING PERMIT NOR OCCUPANCY CERTIFICATE MAY BE ISSUED UNTIL THE RESOLUTION GRANTING THE USE PERMIT/VARIANCE HAS BEEN SIGNED BY THE APPLICANT AND PROPERTY OWNER.  THIS RESOLUTION WILL BE MAILED TO THE APPLICANT FOLLOWING THE PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION.

 

VIII.  JUDICIAL TIME LIMITS

This serves as written notice that Pacific Grove Municipal Code Section 1.20.010 incorporates Section 1094.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure of the State of California and provides a ninety-day limitation for judicial review of any final administrative decision by the council, or any board, commissioner, or officer of the city.

 

This meeting is open to the public and all interested persons are welcome to attend.  The City of Pacific Grove does not discriminate against individuals with disabilities and meetings are held in accessible facilities.